{
  "version": "article-economics-2",
  "sourceReportSha256": "8e513b42f702b2a44c7aea23137ee014fa1e9944589eb11a93c293bc7c8bd989",
  "research": {
    "version": "article-jev-research-economics-1",
    "resultSha256": "3362808ebd76f34898051a88e6f552ae6d820c8f6b9ec699cdd0b4c99ccad29a",
    "inputManifestSha256": "88d29ac86552b28c44d3e7e9c2445ff0cbd00fb380afcc13700b3857cf7774c6",
    "verificationSha256": "c0116c2a1e51d0160952267ba85b9ab4429f1f3f185307073363e565deafef0a",
    "sample": {
      "families": 200,
      "cases": 205,
      "uniqueAtoms": 279,
      "uniqueRows": 903,
      "batches": 52
    },
    "baseLabel": "First corrected Jev run on confirmation panel",
    "baseQuestionKinds": [
      {
        "kind": "type",
        "questions": 293
      },
      {
        "kind": "unit",
        "questions": 293
      },
      {
        "kind": "identity",
        "questions": 118
      },
      {
        "kind": "relation",
        "questions": 12
      }
    ],
    "runs": [
      {
        "id": "original",
        "label": "Original Jev wording",
        "policyLabel": "Original wording",
        "repetition": null,
        "fullAgreement": 166,
        "coreAgreement": 171,
        "validCases": 202,
        "jevCalls": 61,
        "questions": 709,
        "inputTokens": 731452,
        "pricedDollars": 0.030720984000000003,
        "unpricedCalls": 0,
        "elapsedSeconds": 25.855904083000002,
        "serviceSeconds": 50.63883158200001,
        "medianBatchSeconds": 0.7343378340000017,
        "p90BatchSeconds": 1.4136482079999997
      },
      {
        "id": "corrected-1",
        "label": "Corrected Jev · run 1",
        "policyLabel": "Corrected wording",
        "repetition": 1,
        "fullAgreement": 195,
        "coreAgreement": 197,
        "validCases": 203,
        "jevCalls": 66,
        "questions": 716,
        "inputTokens": 801671,
        "pricedDollars": 0.03367018200000001,
        "unpricedCalls": 0,
        "elapsedSeconds": 28.643177124999998,
        "serviceSeconds": 56.204118208000004,
        "medianBatchSeconds": 0.8053542079999988,
        "p90BatchSeconds": 1.7034368330000007
      },
      {
        "id": "corrected-2",
        "label": "Corrected Jev · run 2",
        "policyLabel": "Corrected wording",
        "repetition": 2,
        "fullAgreement": 194,
        "coreAgreement": 196,
        "validCases": 203,
        "jevCalls": 67,
        "questions": 717,
        "inputTokens": 824843,
        "pricedDollars": 0.034643406000000015,
        "unpricedCalls": 0,
        "elapsedSeconds": 33.137635125,
        "serviceSeconds": 65.26725095799999,
        "medianBatchSeconds": 0.9308250000000007,
        "p90BatchSeconds": 1.849932041
      },
      {
        "id": "corrected-3",
        "label": "Corrected Jev · run 3",
        "policyLabel": "Corrected wording",
        "repetition": 3,
        "fullAgreement": 195,
        "coreAgreement": 196,
        "validCases": 203,
        "jevCalls": 66,
        "questions": 716,
        "inputTokens": 801671,
        "pricedDollars": 0.03367018200000001,
        "unpricedCalls": 0,
        "elapsedSeconds": 31.144035457999998,
        "serviceSeconds": 61.249142044000024,
        "medianBatchSeconds": 0.8775607499999988,
        "p90BatchSeconds": 1.6888915829999969
      }
    ],
    "points": [
      {
        "id": "jev-only",
        "label": "Jev only",
        "reviewedFamilies": 0,
        "reviewedCases": 0,
        "fullAgreement": 195,
        "coreAgreement": 197,
        "validCases": 203,
        "repairedFamilies": 0,
        "regressedFamilies": 0,
        "parts": [
          {
            "key": "jev",
            "label": "Jev base",
            "calls": 66,
            "pricedDollars": 0.03367018200000001,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 56.204118208000004
          },
          {
            "key": "review",
            "label": "Completed original reviews",
            "calls": 0,
            "pricedDollars": 0,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 0
          },
          {
            "key": "failed-review",
            "label": "Failed original reviews",
            "calls": 0,
            "pricedDollars": 0,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 0
          },
          {
            "key": "recovery",
            "label": "Explicit recovery",
            "calls": 0,
            "pricedDollars": 0,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 0
          }
        ],
        "pricedDollars": 0.03367018200000001,
        "unpricedCalls": 0,
        "serviceSeconds": 56.204118208000004,
        "elapsedSeconds": 28.643177124999998,
        "baseElapsedSeconds": 28.643177124999998,
        "reviewStageSeconds": null,
        "recoveryStageSeconds": null,
        "stageSumSeconds": null,
        "timingNote": "Measured single-arm Jev invocation; service is the sum of awaited caller times."
      },
      {
        "id": "review-1",
        "label": "1-family review",
        "reviewedFamilies": 1,
        "reviewedCases": 1,
        "fullAgreement": 196,
        "coreAgreement": 198,
        "validCases": 204,
        "repairedFamilies": 1,
        "regressedFamilies": 0,
        "parts": [
          {
            "key": "jev",
            "label": "Jev base",
            "calls": 66,
            "pricedDollars": 0.03367018200000001,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 56.204118208000004
          },
          {
            "key": "review",
            "label": "Completed original reviews",
            "calls": 1,
            "pricedDollars": 0.0025011499999999997,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 13.10752125
          },
          {
            "key": "failed-review",
            "label": "Failed original reviews",
            "calls": 0,
            "pricedDollars": 0,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 0
          },
          {
            "key": "recovery",
            "label": "Explicit recovery",
            "calls": 0,
            "pricedDollars": 0,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 0
          }
        ],
        "pricedDollars": 0.03617133200000001,
        "unpricedCalls": 0,
        "serviceSeconds": 69.311639458,
        "elapsedSeconds": null,
        "baseElapsedSeconds": 28.643177124999998,
        "reviewStageSeconds": null,
        "recoveryStageSeconds": null,
        "stageSumSeconds": null,
        "timingNote": "Prefix elapsed time and review-stage time were not separately measured. Service time sums included whole-family calls plus the entire Jev base."
      },
      {
        "id": "review-2",
        "label": "2-family review",
        "reviewedFamilies": 2,
        "reviewedCases": 2,
        "fullAgreement": 197,
        "coreAgreement": 199,
        "validCases": 205,
        "repairedFamilies": 2,
        "regressedFamilies": 0,
        "parts": [
          {
            "key": "jev",
            "label": "Jev base",
            "calls": 66,
            "pricedDollars": 0.03367018200000001,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 56.204118208000004
          },
          {
            "key": "review",
            "label": "Completed original reviews",
            "calls": 2,
            "pricedDollars": 0.004257199999999999,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 23.823239166
          },
          {
            "key": "failed-review",
            "label": "Failed original reviews",
            "calls": 0,
            "pricedDollars": 0,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 0
          },
          {
            "key": "recovery",
            "label": "Explicit recovery",
            "calls": 0,
            "pricedDollars": 0,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 0
          }
        ],
        "pricedDollars": 0.03792738200000001,
        "unpricedCalls": 0,
        "serviceSeconds": 80.027357374,
        "elapsedSeconds": null,
        "baseElapsedSeconds": 28.643177124999998,
        "reviewStageSeconds": null,
        "recoveryStageSeconds": null,
        "stageSumSeconds": null,
        "timingNote": "Prefix elapsed time and review-stage time were not separately measured. Service time sums included whole-family calls plus the entire Jev base."
      },
      {
        "id": "review-5",
        "label": "5-family review",
        "reviewedFamilies": 5,
        "reviewedCases": 5,
        "fullAgreement": 199,
        "coreAgreement": 199,
        "validCases": 205,
        "repairedFamilies": 4,
        "regressedFamilies": 0,
        "parts": [
          {
            "key": "jev",
            "label": "Jev base",
            "calls": 66,
            "pricedDollars": 0.03367018200000001,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 56.204118208000004
          },
          {
            "key": "review",
            "label": "Completed original reviews",
            "calls": 5,
            "pricedDollars": 0.009790199999999999,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 58.688669874
          },
          {
            "key": "failed-review",
            "label": "Failed original reviews",
            "calls": 0,
            "pricedDollars": 0,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 0
          },
          {
            "key": "recovery",
            "label": "Explicit recovery",
            "calls": 0,
            "pricedDollars": 0,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 0
          }
        ],
        "pricedDollars": 0.043460382000000006,
        "unpricedCalls": 0,
        "serviceSeconds": 114.89278808200001,
        "elapsedSeconds": null,
        "baseElapsedSeconds": 28.643177124999998,
        "reviewStageSeconds": null,
        "recoveryStageSeconds": null,
        "stageSumSeconds": null,
        "timingNote": "Prefix elapsed time and review-stage time were not separately measured. Service time sums included whole-family calls plus the entire Jev base."
      },
      {
        "id": "review-10-first",
        "label": "Ten-family review · first pass",
        "reviewedFamilies": 10,
        "reviewedCases": 11,
        "fullAgreement": 199,
        "coreAgreement": 199,
        "validCases": 205,
        "repairedFamilies": 5,
        "regressedFamilies": 1,
        "parts": [
          {
            "key": "jev",
            "label": "Jev base",
            "calls": 66,
            "pricedDollars": 0.03367018200000001,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 56.204118208000004
          },
          {
            "key": "review",
            "label": "Completed original reviews",
            "calls": 9,
            "pricedDollars": 0.01972175,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 108.90134549899999
          },
          {
            "key": "failed-review",
            "label": "Failed original reviews",
            "calls": 1,
            "pricedDollars": 0.0039417,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 12.076276208000003
          },
          {
            "key": "recovery",
            "label": "Explicit recovery",
            "calls": 0,
            "pricedDollars": 0,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 0
          }
        ],
        "pricedDollars": 0.057333632,
        "unpricedCalls": 0,
        "serviceSeconds": 177.18173991499998,
        "elapsedSeconds": null,
        "baseElapsedSeconds": 28.643177124999998,
        "reviewStageSeconds": 63.855605708000006,
        "recoveryStageSeconds": null,
        "stageSumSeconds": 92.498782833,
        "timingNote": "Combined end-to-end elapsed time was not separately measured. Stage sum adds the separately recorded Jev and ten-family review clocks."
      },
      {
        "id": "review-10-recovered",
        "label": "Ten-family review · with recovery",
        "reviewedFamilies": 10,
        "reviewedCases": 11,
        "fullAgreement": 199,
        "coreAgreement": 199,
        "validCases": 205,
        "repairedFamilies": 5,
        "regressedFamilies": 1,
        "parts": [
          {
            "key": "jev",
            "label": "Jev base",
            "calls": 66,
            "pricedDollars": 0.03367018200000001,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 56.204118208000004
          },
          {
            "key": "review",
            "label": "Completed original reviews",
            "calls": 9,
            "pricedDollars": 0.01972175,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 108.90134549899999
          },
          {
            "key": "failed-review",
            "label": "Failed original reviews",
            "calls": 1,
            "pricedDollars": 0.0039417,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 12.076276208000003
          },
          {
            "key": "recovery",
            "label": "Explicit recovery",
            "calls": 1,
            "pricedDollars": 0.0037185,
            "unpricedCalls": 0,
            "serviceSeconds": 11.388211833000002
          }
        ],
        "pricedDollars": 0.061052132,
        "unpricedCalls": 0,
        "serviceSeconds": 188.569951748,
        "elapsedSeconds": null,
        "baseElapsedSeconds": 28.643177124999998,
        "reviewStageSeconds": 63.855605708000006,
        "recoveryStageSeconds": 11.388211833000002,
        "stageSumSeconds": 103.886994666,
        "timingNote": "Combined end-to-end elapsed time was not separately measured. Stage sum adds recorded Jev, ten-family review and explicit recovery clocks; the original failed call remains included."
      }
    ],
    "studyBill": {
      "pricedDollars": 0.5644491140000008,
      "heldCommitmentDollars": 0.42686199999999996,
      "unpricedAttempts": 4,
      "protectedReserveDollars": 0.5,
      "internalAllocationDollars": 10,
      "authorizationIncreaseDollars": 0
    },
    "sources": [
      {
        "label": "Accepted Jev research results",
        "sha256": "3362808ebd76f34898051a88e6f552ae6d820c8f6b9ec699cdd0b4c99ccad29a"
      },
      {
        "label": "Research input manifest",
        "sha256": "88d29ac86552b28c44d3e7e9c2445ff0cbd00fb380afcc13700b3857cf7774c6"
      },
      {
        "label": "Accepted input verification",
        "sha256": "c0116c2a1e51d0160952267ba85b9ab4429f1f3f185307073363e565deafef0a"
      },
      {
        "label": "Predeclared confirmation policy and prefixes",
        "sha256": "ca151ca289862e5bf123b78e2e00a9b9aac8cd7e436111ab955ecdea26c8ef5b"
      },
      {
        "label": "Original Jev wording · report",
        "sha256": "8ece99387b3cda97c2cd1d6978e0784c172fd52b1f688e9734fba01655bd0043"
      },
      {
        "label": "Corrected Jev · run 1 · report",
        "sha256": "62b5c65c011142a440b57070ccee81848f1cdf7b2ce7c6e08b559ff31ed92732"
      },
      {
        "label": "Corrected Jev · run 2 · report",
        "sha256": "1eac586e82844ab619a27f04bea30ce9797dfa29c4b0a8371a52bf267b43fd04"
      },
      {
        "label": "Corrected Jev · run 3 · report",
        "sha256": "52723534bb0c1557f28c074c72567d44d6d03be6fc57f454a4eb1e304bd074aa"
      },
      {
        "label": "Sparse confirmation prefix report",
        "sha256": "79d748a49bfb4317c1806459af1f44f7ef05bd816180f47c03a1915a27b1c539"
      },
      {
        "label": "Original ten-family review invocation",
        "sha256": "50fe704d93d97ebad0c59d3f66e1a9bffb68b35bac505c31ab9cfa9b465ceb1f"
      },
      {
        "label": "Predeclared same-input recovery",
        "sha256": "00cb2837c8057c94ce03693a2b6ccbaf52114f78aec3609c07033b5b6922165a"
      },
      {
        "label": "Recorded recovery result",
        "sha256": "dbc38cedf0ec51f4c189d943e819c09fffedc57ae63a66cc729d57e87e3500a1"
      },
      {
        "label": "Sealed study funding summary",
        "sha256": "f7e94c6b61991f90dcf9b93354a2825e25c0aea31c8711de894c5a9f6419f19a"
      }
    ],
    "notes": {
      "selection": "The predeclared whole-family queue ranks invalid outputs first, then explicit uncertainty, then minimum selected-choice probability. It is not a fixed confidence cutoff. Source-only Luna sees the complete selected family, not Jev proposals or reference answers.",
      "quality": "Full family agreement is agreement with a model-adjudicated reference, not human accuracy. Luna helped construct that reference: source-only review is not reference-independent. All original families and cases remain in the denominators.",
      "timing": "Service seconds sum awaited caller-wrapper durations, including overhead and unsuccessful included attempts, not provider-only latency. Only Jev-only has a measured single-arm whole invocation; review prefixes have no separately measured combined elapsed time. Stage sums are sums of recorded clocks, not one observed end-to-end run. Repetitions varied in answers, calls and shared-machine conditions; they are not a confidence interval or SLA.",
      "price": "Recorded model estimates, not provider invoices. Whole-family calls are never prorated. Failed original reviews and the explicit recovery remain charged separately. Research overhead and unpriced reservations are separate from deployment-shaped points; the research ceiling was an internal allocation, not new authorization."
    }
  },
  "sample": {
    "families": 200,
    "cases": 205,
    "uniqueRows": 903,
    "uniqueAtoms": 279,
    "rowIncidences": 951,
    "batches": 52,
    "serializedEvidenceBytes": 1204763,
    "minBatchBytes": 9265,
    "maxBatchBytes": 76664,
    "byteDefinition": "UTF-8 bytes of the canonical, escaped model-visible source state, counted once per original batch, including supplied references and repeated per-batch policy. Re-derived states match all 52 retained Fable-primary deliveries. This is a common logical-workload denominator, not raw CSV, distinct knowledge, total network traffic or disk throughput.",
    "timeDefinition": "Sum of full awaited component-call durations, including priced/unpriced attempts and native startup/accounting where applicable. Not independent wall-clock makespan; the arms were interleaved with two batch workers."
  },
  "arms": [
    {
      "id": "fable",
      "models": [
        {
          "model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5-1",
          "label": "Fable 5.1",
          "calls": 52,
          "pricedDollars": 9.831786999999998,
          "unpricedCalls": 0,
          "heldCommitmentDollars": 0,
          "serviceSeconds": 844.6439144199999
        }
      ],
      "heldCommitmentDollars": 0,
      "evidenceKBPerServiceSecond": 1.426356100401536,
      "pricedDollarsPerEvidenceKB": 0.008160764399305092,
      "rowsPerServiceSecond": 1.0690895708638022
    },
    {
      "id": "cheap",
      "models": [
        {
          "model": "pi/openai/gpt-5.6-luna",
          "label": "Luna",
          "calls": 52,
          "pricedDollars": 0.16846504999999995,
          "unpricedCalls": 8,
          "heldCommitmentDollars": 2.8000000000000003,
          "serviceSeconds": 608.4847014639998
        },
        {
          "model": "pi/google/gemini-3.7-flash",
          "label": "Gemini 3.7 Flash",
          "calls": 10,
          "pricedDollars": 0.1327815,
          "unpricedCalls": 0,
          "heldCommitmentDollars": 0,
          "serviceSeconds": 106.59963216599994
        }
      ],
      "heldCommitmentDollars": 2.8000000000000003,
      "evidenceKBPerServiceSecond": 1.6847844979126196,
      "pricedDollarsPerEvidenceKB": 0.00025004631616342804,
      "rowsPerServiceSecond": 1.2627881181735294
    },
    {
      "id": "jev-first",
      "models": [
        {
          "model": "jev-1.13.0",
          "label": "Jev",
          "calls": 65,
          "pricedDollars": 0.03204112800000001,
          "unpricedCalls": 1,
          "heldCommitmentDollars": 0.097986,
          "serviceSeconds": 47.351881168000006
        },
        {
          "model": "pi/openai/gpt-5.6-luna",
          "label": "Luna",
          "calls": 31,
          "pricedDollars": 0.0479531,
          "unpricedCalls": 3,
          "heldCommitmentDollars": 1.0499999999999998,
          "serviceSeconds": 209.35622162500007
        },
        {
          "model": "pi/google/gemini-3.7-flash",
          "label": "Gemini 3.7 Flash",
          "calls": 3,
          "pricedDollars": 0.032379000000000005,
          "unpricedCalls": 0,
          "heldCommitmentDollars": 0,
          "serviceSeconds": 33.509490666
        }
      ],
      "heldCommitmentDollars": 1.1479859999999997,
      "evidenceKBPerServiceSecond": 4.151240404280316,
      "pricedDollarsPerEvidenceKB": 0.00009327413607489608,
      "rowsPerServiceSecond": 3.1114585068309086
    }
  ],
  "jev": {
    "requests": 65,
    "questions": 715,
    "acceptedByGate": 663,
    "referredByGate": 52,
    "noReasoningCases": 165,
    "reasoningCases": 40,
    "byKind": [
      {
        "kind": "type",
        "asked": 293,
        "accepted": 273
      },
      {
        "kind": "unit",
        "asked": 293,
        "accepted": 265
      },
      {
        "kind": "identity",
        "asked": 118,
        "accepted": 116
      },
      {
        "kind": "relation",
        "asked": 11,
        "accepted": 9
      }
    ],
    "requestBodyBytes": 2394019,
    "serviceSeconds": 47.351881168000006,
    "pricedDollars": 0.03204112800000001
  },
  "studyBill": {
    "authorizedDollars": 85,
    "pricedDollars": 31.985710472,
    "comparisonPricedDollars": 10.245406777999998,
    "otherPricedDollars": 21.740303694000005,
    "heldCommitmentDollars": 9.583791,
    "protectedReserveDollars": 3.7,
    "scope": "New article study only, including development and failed/superseded model attempts. Unknown charges are not zero. Catalogue estimates are not invoices; D28/prior-reference construction, local compute and 4a authoring costs are excluded."
  },
  "ohio": {
    "snapshot": "oh@2026-06-11",
    "contributionRows": 883012,
    "contributionRawBytes": 189908438,
    "strictBundles": 283349,
    "files": [
      {
        "name": "CAN_CON_2022.csv",
        "bytes": 42849560,
        "rows": 193908,
        "sha256": "3d9fb4dbf9ac4566133a1ec6c59cbb1c3a6496ec4f998723d8ae3f5d3c212da3"
      },
      {
        "name": "CAN_CON_2024.csv",
        "bytes": 18579375,
        "rows": 86093,
        "sha256": "85fe77136977012201c88203334703cd4268f36ca1e7c2dd2e3ac352172b5e00"
      },
      {
        "name": "PAC_CON_2022.csv",
        "bytes": 72574196,
        "rows": 339888,
        "sha256": "5d3113b35c3267f010622c91a04e32f55d3005870d14182d07c4d11fc8cdce91"
      },
      {
        "name": "PAC_CON_2024.csv",
        "bytes": 55905307,
        "rows": 263123,
        "sha256": "3a963fc2470cdf240b82544a5886c99f293857944a8bf0b2d724ff41e4ce59b7"
      }
    ],
    "scope": "The four held candidate-committee and PAC contribution CSVs for report years 2022 and 2024, captured in June 2026. Not all historical Ohio filings; report year is not necessarily transaction year. Cover registries, later PARTY files and DIME are separate references. Strict bundles group identical evidence under the checked normalization contract; they are not resolved donor identities.",
    "sourceUrl": "https://www.ohiosos.gov/campaign-finance/search/"
  },
  "tokenPrice": {
    "inputDollarsPerMillion": 0.042,
    "outputDollarsPerMillion": 0,
    "checkedOn": "2026-09-17",
    "sourceUrl": "https://docs.typesafe.ai/models"
  }
}